Proposal Strategy

Sep 04, 2024

Winning Proposals: A Strategic Approach

Winning proposals don’t happen by accident. They are the result of careful planning and strategic execution. Tired of pouring countless hours into proposals that fall short? It’s a frustrating reality, but there is a better way. 

winning proposals

Here, you’ll discover proven strategies, practical tips, and actionable insights for efficiently developing proposals that truly resonate with your clients and drive positive outcomes. 

Winning proposals

Winning proposals are more than just a document deliverable; they are strategic tools designed to persuade clients to choose your solution over the competitor’s solution. 

Whether you are bidding E&R, construction, government, or just about any other competitive industry, winning proposals resonate with readers because they are: 

  • Client-Focused: Demonstrate that you understand them and their situation. 
  • Benefits-Driven: Showcase your solution’s value through the desired outcomes.
  • Evidence-Supported: Highlight client proof of your solution’s benefits.
  • Easy-to-Understand: Make it easy to read, navigate and evaluate.  

When these elements are combined, they create a proposal that is informative, persuasive, and effective in driving client engagement and decision-making.

Planning a Winning Proposal

Planning a winning proposal is about more than just coordinating experts, tasks and timelines. It’s about positioning your team for the win. By investing time and effort into planning proposal development, you significantly increase your chances of persuading clients over to your way of thinking. 

Capture Management Strategy

The capture strategy defines how your business will win a specific contact, project, or opportunity. This includes pre-RFP or Tender research and analysis into the client’s needs, and the competitors strengths and weaknesses. The result is a plan that moves your business from a potential unknown or outlier position to the position of preferred supplier or partner - before the RFP or Tender is released. 

Best practice capture management approaches include:

  • Begin Early: Identify the opportunity early, about 12 - 24 months before the RFP or Tender, and prepare to research, analyze, and build relationships. 
  • Understand the Client: Identify their challenges and needs, their pain points and hot buttons, requirements and goals, as well as their fears and objections.
  • Investigate the Competition: Evaluate their background and market position, marketing strategy and client base. Conduct a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) exercise to review similar past proposals from key competitors or incumbents. Analyze their value proposition, win themes, and evidence. 
  • Conduct a SWOT Analysis: Use the tried and true Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) analysis framework to evaluate your competitor position and develop a strategic capture plan.

By getting involved in the pre-RFP or Tender sales and capture process, proposal managers can proactively influence the direction of the proposal they will be tasked with developing. This allows them to identify challenges early, gather essential information and resources, and develop an effective proposal win strategy. 

Proposal Win Strategy 

A targeted proposal win strategy is the cornerstone of effective proposal development. While it includes resources, tasks and timelines, it also includes key capture details. These details guide your experts in their writing to optimize their time and ensure they deliver the outcomes you expect.  

Leverage what you’ve learned from the capture phase to develop the keys to your proposal win strategy: 

  • Winning Value Propositions make the case for your business as the problem-solver, and are easy to communicate and remember. 
  • Winning Win Themes resonate with what the client wants and echo your value proposition across the proposal, making it memorable. 
  • Winning Differentiators are specialized, relevant, true, and provable, and directly support your value proposition and win themes.  
  • Winning Discriminators focus on people, experience and performance to demonstrate your understanding of the client’s goals and objectives. 
  • Winning Proof Points showcase how your solution solved a relevant client problem and achieved measurable results. 

By arming your proposal experts and contributors with these strategic components, you empower them to create documents that are more tailored, focused and persuasive. Without major revisions.

How to Write a Winning Proposal

Before asking your contributors to put pen to paper, take time to annotate your proposal outline with the strategic components you defined as part of your win strategy. 

By highlighting each section’s key themes, differentiators, discriminators and proof points, you communicate what is expected in the first draft. Add in the section’s specific evaluation criteria and you guide them down a writing path that is more likely to lead to what the client expects and prioritizes. 

As they write, they’ll use these guiding details to: 

  • Hook the reader by opening with an anecdote, question or fact that reminds the reader about the problem they are trying to solve.  
  • Craft a compelling story that positions the readers as the hero, and weaves in examples and anecdotes that help them see the big picture and connect the dots.  
  • Demonstrate industry knowledge by echoing your value proposition through your management approach, and how past experiences have shaped it.  
  • Showcase your track record by highlighting your differentiators through your battle-tested implementation or project approach. 
  • Empathize with readers by speaking about their concerns, objections and fears and how you overcome them. 
  • Ghost the competition, without naming them, by showcasing your discriminators through the executive summary and key section introductions. 
  • Support all claims with evidence that elevates your credibility every step of the way, from executive summary to conclusion.

Suggested content:

More on winning proposals below!
THREE60 Energy Norway
XaitPorter

THREE60 Energy Norway

THREE60 Energy Norway writes proposals faster while increasing quality with XaitPorter. 

August 28, 2024

Argeo
XaitPorter

Argeo

Argeo saves “a tremendous amount of time” by eliminating expert silos, lengthy content searches, and manual hand-offs with XaitPorter.

August 06, 2024

DeepOcean
XaitPorter

DeepOcean

Ocean services provider DeepOcean uses XaitPorter to focus on what matters – quality content in their tenders

July 02, 2023

 

How to Strengthen Your Proposal

The first draft is written and it’s right on target. Now you have time to evaluate your proposal and identify areas where you can strengthen your proposal communication. 

A thorough review and revision process can significantly enhance the clarity, persuasiveness and overall impact of your document. Here are some key areas to focus on:

  • Review with Vigor: A team of reviewers, armed with your capture and win strategy, bring important perspective to your proposal. Ask them for instructions, not opinions, to build a roadmap of revisions that enhance value and readability.   
  • Revise with Focus: Based on the time that remains, prioritize revisions by focusing first on compliance and second on boosting your evaluation score. Add context where concepts are challenging. Add evidence where claims lack proof. 
  • Bring Clarity and Coherence: Help readers understand and follow-along by keeping it short and relevant. Add visuals to help tell the story and reach different types of readers. Break up long sections with subheadings that drive the story forward. 
  • Simulate Evaluation: Recruit fresh eyes for an independent review and officially score your proposal - focus on how to move the evaluation score needle forward on each section.

This step of your proposal development process helps to strengthen your proposal's value proposition by ensuring it effectively communicates your message. 

Build a Strong Proposal Contributor Team

Assembling a team of skilled experts and contributors who understand the proposal win strategy is just a part of the winning proposal puzzle. To deliver a winning proposal, you must also empower this team with tactics and teamwork.

By providing targeted training and fostering a collaborative environment, you can empower your team members to write effectively and efficiently.

  • Cultivate Open Communication: Walk through the win strategy together, and invite questions and debate. Bring marketing in to discuss positioning and messaging, and executives to talk about how this project will impact the business.  
  • Empower Your team: Discuss strategies for creating a compelling and memorable proposal. Provide on-demand workshops on storytelling and persuasive writing and how to connect with reader’s emotions. Demonstrate the power of data and how it drives decision-making. 
  • Foster Real-time Collaboration: Centralize your win strategy for easy access and consultation. Centralize your proposal development so experts and contributors can work together real-time.

Collaborative Power: The Secret Weapon

One of the biggest frustrations experts and contributors have with developing winning proposals is lack of continuity. They may all be working toward a common goal, a winning proposal, but they are still all working individually on siloed sections. 

They can’t see who else is working on the larger document and communicate with them. They can’t see what they are writing and connect with it. When it’s time to compile the sections into the proposal, content is fragmented and disconnected, which means more work for you, reviewers, experts and contributors to fix. 

When you knock down those silos, you foster clear communications that keep everyone in sync, no matter where or when they work. They are more efficient and productive, and more likely to hit their deadlines with ease. 

  • Better Expertise Leveraging: Everyone easily shares their expertise and insights, leading to a stronger and more informative proposal. 
  • Enhanced Coherence and Consistency: Everyone ensures a consistent tone, style, and message, as well as accuracy and transitions between sections.
  • Greater Visibility into Progress and Status: Meanwhile, management can keep their finger on the pulse of progress, and step in before a bottleneck becomes a delay.

Conclusion

In the competitive world of winning proposals, a well-crafted, strategic proposal makes all the difference. By carefully planning, thoughtfully executing and fostering team collaboration you can increase your chances of being understood, persuading clients, and securing the projects you desire. 

Remember, proposal win strategy and teamwork makes the winning proposal dream work

XaitPorter - Co-authoring software for tenders and RFPs

Our senior proposal specialist. Cheryl has 20+ years of experience managing and writing for U.S. government contractors.

More on proposal strategy:

Proposal deadlines: Challenges and strategies
Proposal Process

Proposal deadlines: Challenges and strategies

Meeting proposal deadlines is crucial in the highly competitive world of tenders and RFPs. Missing a deadline can not only result in disqua...

September 04, 2024

Winning Proposals: A Strategic Approach
Proposal Strategy

Winning Proposals: A Strategic Approach

Winning proposals don’t happen by accident. They are the result of careful planning and strategic execution. Tired of pouring countless hou...

September 04, 2024

Proposal Win Strategy
Proposal Process

Proposal Win Strategy

A proposal win strategy is a comprehensive plan outlining how your team will write a proposal that commands attention and sets your busines...

September 04, 2024